Izvorni znanstveni članak
ACCENTUATION OF THE KNOWN AND REPETION OF UNTRUTHS: ABOUT THE BOOK John Cornwell, Hitler's Pope. The Secrete History of Pius XII, Viking, London, 1999, 430 pages.
Jure Krišto
; Hrvatski institut za povijest, Zagreb, Hrvatska
Sažetak
While the author is impressed by Cornwell's style and presentation, he is appaled by the lack of seriousness exhibited by author who writes about an important subject (not broached for the first time, by any means) and by demonstrated inability to supress his preconceived notions and even prejudices. Cornwell relies heavily on Owen Chadwick, which assures that he mentions most important facts about the involvement of the Cardinal and Pope Pius XII (whom Cornwell systematicaly entitles by his family name, Pacelli) in contemporary politics, but he bends and ignores Chadwick's research when he makes his judgment about the Pope.
Cornwell's treatment of Catholic Church in the Independent Stale of Croatia (he gives it an entire chapter) is a traversy of research and objective writing. His main source, if not the only, for the presentation of the Church in Croatia during the World War li is 35 years old book by Carlo Falconi. Cornwell perhaps did not know, but he could have and must have been informed, that Falconi wrote his piece on the basis of the propagandistic material given to him by the Yugoslav secrete service and propagandists, which served the purpose of anti-Chatolic propaganda in Yugoslavia. A well intended reader could excuse Cornwell (he does not read Croatian and could not know what some authors wrote about Falconi's sources at the time his book appeared), if he did not point those "Croatian materials" as essential not only for the condemnation of Croatian Catholic episcopate, but for Pius XII as well.
Ključne riječi
Hrčak ID:
207141
URI
Datum izdavanja:
2.7.2000.
Posjeta: 775 *