Pregledni rad
https://doi.org/10.22586/csp.v51i2.8728
From Chronology towards Theoretical Concepts – the Problem of Émigrés in Croatian Historiography as Evidenced by Papers Published in the Journal of Contemporary History
Ivan Hrstić
orcid.org/0000-0003-2445-3533
; Institut društvenih znanosti Ivo Pilar, Zagreb, Hrvatska
Marica Marinović Golubić
orcid.org/0000-0002-5650-3040
; Institut društvenih znanosti Ivo Pilar, Zagreb, Hrvatska
Sažetak
This article encompasses an analysis of research on the process of the formation and development of Croatian émigré communities in Croatian historiography based on 39 papers devoted to this topic, published from 1969 to 2018. The analysis was conducted on two levels. The general (under)representation of the topic in the context of Croatian historiography as a whole is examined first, followed by the issue of the influence of the dominant narrative on research through three key domains: the selection of topics, the use of characteristic methodology, and the interpretation itself. In this context, two periods have been examined separately – during the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and after the Republic of Croatia achieved independence. Parallel with this part of the analysis, the basic characteristics of papers on the topic of Croatian émigrés have been contextualised in regard to the achievements of foreign historiography and related scientific disciplines from the aspect of applying theoretical and methodological research frameworks.
The reasons for the poor representation of this topic include high politicisation in regard to the critical stance of a large part of the émigré population towards the political system in Yugoslavia till 1991 and the difficult accessibility of archival material and relevant literature on immigrant associations. The analysis did not find any direct influence of politics, i.e. ideology, on the researchers, but there was a shift in the focus of research in line with changes in the social context, from the (pro-)Yugoslav émigré communities towards the predominantly anti-Yugoslav ones in works published after 1991. The predominant characteristic of the analysed works in both periods is the lack of an interpretation of the activities of examined individuals, events, and processes in a broader theoretical framework. Accordingly, a narrow focus on sources is predominant in the methodological sense, as is the lack of contextualisation of the development of Croatian émigré communities within the frame of immigrant associations. They are approached as homogenous groups, and their development is primarily interpreted in the context of events in Croatia. Following everything stated above, this paper points to the necessity of applying developed theoretical and methodological models through an interdisciplinary perspective.
Ključne riječi
Croatian émigrés; historiography; social history; interdisciplinary approach; Journal of Contemporary History
Hrčak ID:
224474
URI
Datum izdavanja:
13.9.2019.
Posjeta: 1.735 *