THE (NON) JUSTIFICATION OF LOWERING THE AGE OF CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY IN THE FEDERATION OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/31357Keywords:
juvenile offenders, children in conflict with the law, lowering the age of criminal responsibilityAbstract
In the middle of 2023, a thirteen-year-old elementary school student in Lukavac (Bosnia and Herzegovina) shot a teacher with a firearm, causing him life-threatening injuries. It happened just one month after a much more monstrous crime had been committed by his peer in a school in Belgrade. Taking into consideration that in accordance with the positive (juvenile) criminal legislation in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, young persons of that age cannot be prosecuted by the criminal justice authorities, because the age limit for the onset of criminal responsibility is 14 years, in light of the aforementioned events, one of the vice presidents of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina submitted an initiative to the competent Ministry of Justice to amend the relevant legislation by lowering, or redefining the age limit for the onset of criminal responsibility. The paper presents different models of defining the age limits of criminal responsibility in comparative law, as well as tendencies related to their lowering, i.e. raising in the national laws of countries around the world in the last few decades. After that, the paper analyses the relevant international and supranational legal standards in this area, as well as the results of certain (neuro) scientific research related to this issue. Based on all of the above, it is concluded that the initiative to lower or redefine the age of criminal responsibility in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina does not have a valid scientific and legal foundation and that it represents a kind of moral panic and penal populism.
References
Božićević-Grbić M i Roksandić Vidlička S, ’Reforma maloljetničkog kaznenog prava i sudovanja’ (2011) 2 Hrvatski ljetopis za kazneno pravo i praksu
Brown A i Charles A, ’The Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: The Need for a Holistic Approach’ (2021) 2 Youth Justice
Carić A., Mlađe osobe u kaznenom pravu (počinitelji i žrtve) (Pravni fakultet u Zagrebu 2002)
Cipriani D, Children's Rights and the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A Global Perspective (Routledge 2016)
Ćopić S, ’Snižavanje starosne granice krivične odgovornosti: večita dilema?’ (2023) 3 Crimen
Ćorović E i Ganić S, ’Osnovne karakteristike šerijatskog krivičnog prava u poređenju sa dominantnim krivičnopravnim sistemima’, (2016) 3 Strani pravni život
Crofts T, ’A Brighter Tomorrow: Raise the Age of Criminal Responsibility’ (2015) 1 Current Issues in Criminal Justice
Daniluk P i Mierzwińska-Lorencka J, ’Responsibility of a Juvenile for a Prohibited Act under Polish Law’ (2016) 2 International and Comparative Law Review
Delmage E, ’The Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A Medico-Legal Perspective’ (2013) 13 Youth Justice
Dragičević Prtenjača M i Bezić R, ’Perspektiva uvođenja doktrine doli incapax u hrvatsko maloljetničko kazneno pravo’ (2018) 1 Makedonska revija za kazneno pravo i kriminologiju
Decker S i Marteache N (eds.), International Handbook of Juvenile Justice, Second Edition (Springer 2017)
Dunkel F, Grzywa J, Horsfield Ph. i Pruin I. (eds), Juvenile Justice Systems in Europe: Current Situation and Reform Developments (2th edition) (Forum Verlag Godesberg 2011)
Goldson B, ’Unsafe, Unjust and Harmful to Wider Society: Grounds for Raising the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility in England and Wales’ (2013) 1 Youth Justice
Gurda V, ’Pravna priroda i izvršenje zavodske mjere upućivanja u odgojnu ustanovu u Bosni i Hercegovini’ (2018) 58 Pravna riječ
Gurda V, ’Starosne granice krivično-pravnog maloljetstva u uporednom pravu’ (2020) 3 Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci
Ioan B, Damian S, Scripcaru C, Neagu M i Chirila B, ’From Punishment to Education – Juvenile Delinquency in Romanian Criminal Law’ (2015) 1 Revista medico-chirurgicala a Societatii de Medici si Naturalisti din Iasi
Lazin Đ, Posebni i pomoćni krivični postupci (Kultura 1995)
Marković D i Spaić I, ’Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility as Part of Criminal Policies’ (2022) 3 Kultura polisa
McAra L i McVie S, ’Raising the Minimum age of Criminal Responsibility: Lessons from the Scottish Experience’ (2023) Current Issues in Criminal Justice
Orlić S, Pehlić I i Tufekčić N, Maloljetničko prestupništvo (Islamski pedagoški fakultet 2019)
Papadodimitraki Y, Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility (MACR) – Comparative Analysis International Profile – New Zealand (2016) CYCJ – Centre for Youth and Criminal Justice
Radić I, ’Hrvatski sustav maloljetničkih sankcija: trenutačno stanje i prijedlozi za promjenu’ (2017) 1 Hrvatski ljetopis za kaznene znanosti i praksu
Simović M, Jovašević D, Mitrović Lj i Simović M, Maloljetničko krivično pravo (treće izdanje) (GrafoMark 2021)
Škulić M i Stevanović I, ’Pregled posebnih odredaba o maloletnim učiniocima krivičnih dela u uporednom krivičnopravnom zakonodavstvu evropskih zemalja’ (2002) 3 Bilten sudske prakse Vrhovnog suda Srbije
Wiers, I, ’The Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility in Continental Europe Has a Solid Rational Base’ (2016) 3 Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
Živković N, ’Krivična neodgovornost dece – zločin bez kazne i moguća rešenja’ (2020) 3 Strani pravni život
PRAVNI AKTI
Generalni komentar Komiteta UN-a za prava djeteta broj 24 o pravima djece u sistemu pravosuđa za djecu (2019)
Konvencija UN o pravima djeteta (1989) (SL SFRJ, broj 15/1990)
Standardna minimalna pravila UN-a za maloljetničko pravosuđe
Zakon o zaštiti i postupanju sa djecom i maloljetnicima u krivičnom postupku, Službene novine FbiH, broj 7/2014 i 74/2020 (BiH)
Zakon o ustanovama socijalne zaštite Federacije Bosne i Hercegovine, Službene novine FbiH, broj 64/2022 (BiH)
MREŽNI IZVORI
<https://www.justice.act.gov.au/safer-communities/raising-the-age/> pristupljeno 22. februara 2024.
<https://www.njjn.org/our-work/raising-the-minimum-age-for-prosecuting-children/> pristupljeno 12. marta 2024.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Vedad Gurda
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors retain the copyright on the papers published in the Journal, but grant the right of first publication to the Journal. Papers accepted for publication or already published in Pravni vjesnik of the Faculty of Law in Osijek may be published by the author(s) in other publications only with proper notice of its previous publication in Pravni vjesnik.
