VALUE EDUCATION IN LAW SCHOOL CURRICULUM
CULTIVATING MORAL AUTONOMY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/28586Keywords:
ERR framework, legal education, moral reasoning, critical pedagogy, value education, valuesAbstract
According to the EU Justice Scoreboard reports, over 70% of Croatian citizens are dissatisfied with the Croatian judiciary, particularly its independence and efficiency. This paper addresses the deep-rooted challenges in the country’s legal education system. Despite reform initiatives, the current system serially produces ‘legal technicians’ lacking values, critical thinking capacity, and active student engagement. This echoes Montesquieu’s depiction of legal practitioners as ‘mouths that pronounce the words of the law.’ Acknowledging the pivotal role of legal education methodology in the creation of future legal practitioners and legal culture, this contribution explores how an average regular educator can support the development of students’ moral reasoning and values awareness. Through predominantly analytical research methods, we critically examine whether higher education environments should incorporate value education, the feasibility of teaching values in the traditional sense, and the potential of ethical analysis in a classroom to truly influence ethical behaviour in practice. Furthermore, we explore the complex matter of authority to decide on values to be imparted and delve into value education methodology. Concluding with practical suggestions, we propose the integration of the Evocation-Realization of meaning-Reflection (ERR) framework into lectures, as well as various creative tools to enhance moral reasoning.
References
Adorno T W, ‘Education after Auschwitz’ (1998) 191 Critical models: Interventions and catchwords
Apple M W and King N R, ‘What do schools teach?’ in Giroux, H A, David E P (eds), The hidden curriculum and moral education: Deception or discovery? (McCutchan Publishing, Berkeley, 1983) 82–99
Arthur J, ‘Education with character: The moral economy of schooling’ (Routlege, London – New York, 2003)
Babić M, ‘Between National Identity and National Culture. A View from the Balkans’ in Adamczyk A and others (eds) Balkan Ambitions and Polish Inspirations (Centre for Europe, University of Warsaw, Warsaw, 2022) 173–184
Baldus C and Finkenauer T and Rüfner T, ‘Juristenausbildung in Europa zwischen Tradition und Reform‘ (Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, 2008)
Ball D L and Wilson S M, ‘Integrity in Teaching: Recognizing the Fusion of the Moral and Intellectual’ (1996) 33(1) American Educational Research Journal, 155–192
Bardi A and Schwartz S H, ‘Relations among sociopolitical values in Eastern Europe: Effects of the communist experience?’ (1996) 17(3) Political Psychology, 525–549
Bartlett K T, ‘Teaching Values: A Dilemma’ (1987) 37(4) Journal of Legal Education, 519–521
Berdica J, ‘Obrazovanje za vrline, ili: Kakvo nam obrazovanje (ne) treba?’ [‘Education for virtues, or: What kind of education do we (not) need?’] in Koprek I (ed), Vrline i poslovna etika (FTI Družbe Isusove Zagreb, Zagreb, 2015) 39–55
Berk L E, ‘Dječja razvojna psihologija’ [‘Child development’] (8th edition, Slap, Jastrebarsko, 2015)
Berkowitz M and Battistich V and Bier M, ‘What works in character education: What is known and what needs to be known’, in Nucci S, Narvaez D (eds), Handbook of moral and character education (Routledge, New York, 2008) 414–431
Bok D C, ‘Can Ethics Be Taught?’, (1976) 8(9) Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 26–30
Brković V and Kardum R B and Mališa S, ‘Odgoj za vrijednosti u okvirima kurikula predmeta društveno-humanističkoga područja’ [‘Values Education with respect to Subjects in the Fields of the Humanities and Social Sciences’] (2021) 76(2) Obnovljeni Život, 185–201
Campbell E, ‘Connecting the Ethics of Teaching and Moral Education’ (1997) 48 (4) Journal of Teacher Education, 255–263
Choi J H and others, ‘ChatGPT Goes to Law School’ (2023) Journal of Legal Education (Forthcoming), 1–16, available at: <https://ssrn.com/abstract=4335905> accessed 18th September 2023
Cox E, ‘Explicit and Implicit Moral Education’ (1988) 17(2) Journal of Moral Education, 92–97
Ćurko B and others, ‘Ethika. Ethics and Values Education – Manual for Teachers and Educators’, (2015) available at: <https://ec.europa.eu/programmes/erasmus-plus/project-result-content/78cf8290-e6f6-4f2e-bfb6-b6dc88d71100/Ethika_O1a_%20Manual%20for%20Teachers_HR.pdf> accessed 27th September 2023
Du Plessis P, ‘Legal history and method(s)’ (2010) 16(1) Fundamina: A Journal of Legal History, 64–72
Elkins J R, ‘The Pedagogy of Ethics’ (1985) 10 Journal of the Legal Profession, 37–84
Eisgruber C L, ‘Can Law Schools Teach Values’ (2002) 36(3) University of San Francisco Law Review, 603–620
Ferić I, ‘Vrijednosti i vrijednosni sustavi: psihologijski pristup’ [‘Values and value systems: a psychological approach’] (Alinea, Zagreb, 2009)
Ferris G, ‘Uses of value in legal education’ (Intersentia, Cambridge, 2015)
Flavell J H, ‘Cognitive Development’ (Prentice-Hall, New Yersey, 1977)
Giroux H A, ‘Critical Theory and Rationality in Citizenship Education’, in Giroux H A, David E P (eds), The hidden curriculum and moral education: Deception or discovery? (McCutchan Publishing, Berkeley, 1983) 321–360
Giroux H A, ‘Education and the Crisis of Public Values: Challenging the Assault on Teachers, Students, and Public Education’ (Counterpoints: Studies in the Postmodern Theory of Education 400, Peter Lang, New York, 2011)
Greene J D and others, 'An fMRI Investigation of Emotional Engagement in Moral Judgment' (2001) 293 Science, 2105–2108
Halstead J M, ‘Values and values education in schools’, in Halstead J M, Taylor M J (eds), Values in education and education in values (The Palmer Press, New York, Washington, 1996) 11–22
Halstead J M, ‘Liberal Values and Liberal Education’, in Halstead J M, Taylor M J (eds), Values in education and education in values (The Palmer Press, New York, Washington, 1996) 24–36
Hartwell S, ‘Promoting Moral Development through Experiential Teaching’ (1995) 1(3) Clinical Law Review, 505–540
Hazard G C, ‘The Legal Profession, The Impact of Law and Legal Theory, Foreword’ (1998) 67(2) Fordham Law Review, 239–248
Hornbeck D W, ‘Does Values Education Belong in the Curriculum?’ (1987) 8 Curriculum, 1–14
Husu J, ‘Real-world pedagogical ethics: mission impossible?’ (2003) 7(2) Teacher Development, 311–326
Huttunen R, ‘Indoctrination and the Un-growth of Morality’ in Peters M A (ed), Encyclopedia of Educational Philosophy and Theory (Singapore, Springer, 2016) 1135–1142
Kasap J and Lachner V and Žiha N, ‘Through legal education towards European Education Area’ in Duić D and Petrašević T (eds), EU and comparative law issues and challenges series ECLIC (Faculty of Law, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek, Osijek, 2018) 252–274
Kirschenbaum H, ‘A Comprehensive Model for Values Education and Moral Education’ (1992) 73(10) The Phi Delta Kappan, 771–776
Kirschenbaum H, ‘100 ways to enhance values and morality in schools and youth settings’ (Allyn and Bacon, Boston, 1995)
Killen M and Smetana J G, ‘Origins and development of morality’ in Lamb M E (ed), Handbook of child psychology and developmental science (3(7), 2015) 701–749
Kluckhohn C, ‘Values and value-orientations in the theory of action: An exploration in definition and classification’ in Parsons T, Shils E (eds), Toward a general theory of action, (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1951) 388–433
Kohlberg L and Mayer R, ‘Development as the aim of education’ (1972) 42 Harvard Educational Review, 449–496
Kohlberg L, ‘The Psychology of Moral Development: The Nature and Validity of Moral Stages’ (Essays on Moral Development, 2, Harper & Row, 1984)
Kranjc J, ‘Towards Creating the Bologna Curricula Some Thoughts on the Bologna Reform’ (2005) 2(2) Slovenian Law Review, 157–166
Kranjc J, ‘Les réformes de l’université et des études de droit pendant la Yougoslavie socialiste: le cas de la Faculté de droit de l’Université de Ljubljana’ (2015) 35 Revue d'histoire des facultés de droit et de la culture juridique, du monde des juristes et du livre juridique, 191–220
Larson J L, ‘Critical thinking in Slovakia after socialism’ (University of Rochester Press, Rochester, 2013)
Lerner A M, ‘Using Our Brains: What Cognitive Science and Social Psychology Teach Us about Teaching Law Students to Make Ethical, Professionally Responsible, Choices’ (2004) 23(3) Queensland Law Reporter, 643–706
Lewin K, ‘Some social-psychological differences between the United States and Germany’ (1936) 4 Character & Personality; A Quarterly for Psychodiagnostics & Allied Studies, 265–293
Lind G, ‘The meaning and measurement of moral judgment competence. A dual-aspect model’, in Fasko, Jr D and Willis W (eds), Contemporary philosophical and psycho-logical perspectives on moral development and education (Hampton Press, Creskill, 2008), 185–220, available at: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/45817666_The_meaning_and_measurement_of_moral_judgment_competence_A_dual-Aspect_model> accessed 25th September 2023
Mentkowski M and others, ‘Learning that lasts: Integrating learning, development, and performance in college and beyond’ (Jossey-Bass, Hoboken, NJ, 2000)
Meredith K S and Steele J L, ‘Learning and understanding’ in Kollarikova A and others (eds) Critical thinking II (State Pedagogical Institute of Slovakia, Bratislava, 1997)
Meredith K S and Steele J L and Kikušová S, ‘Critical issues: Democracy, community, self, literacy, and the value of global conversation’ (2001) 33(1) Journal of Literacy Research, 169–202
Moliterno J E, ‘An analysis of ethics teaching in law schools: replacing lost benefits of the apprentice system in the academic atmosphere’, (1991) 60 University of Cinncinati Law Review, 83–134
Morris G H, ‘Teaching with Emotion: Enriching the Educational Experience of First-Year Law Students’ (2010) 47(2) San Diego Law Review, 465–520
Myyry L, ‘Moral Judgments and Values’, in’ Kurtz L R (ed), Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, & Conflict (3rd Edition, Academic Press, 2022), 331–338, available at: <https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/social-sciences/moral-judgement>, accessed 23rd September 2023
Narvaez D and Lapsley D K, ‘Teaching moral character: two alternatives for teacher education’ (2007) 43 The Teacher Educator, 156–172
Nicholson C, ‘The relevance of the past in preparing for the future: A case for Roman law and legal history’ (2010) 17(2) Fundamina: A Journal of Legal History, 101–114
Nucci L and Turiel E, ‘Capturing the complexity of moral development and education’ (2009) 3(3) Mind, brain, and education, 151–159
Nussbaum M C, ‘Not for profit: Why democracy needs the humanities’ (Princeton university press, Princeton, 2010)
Penner J G, ‘Why Many College Teachers Cannot Lecture: How to Avoid Communication Breakdown in the Classroom’ (Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, 1984)
Piaget J, ‘The Moral Judgement of a Child’ (The Free Press Glencoe, Illinois, 1948)
Posner R A, ‘The deprofessionalization of legal teaching and scholarship’ (1992) 91(8) Michigan Law Review, 1921–1928
Rakić V and Vukušić S, ‘Odgoj i obrazovanje za vrijednosti’ [‘Education for values’], (2010) 19(4-5) Društvena istraživanja: časopis za opća društvena pitanja, 771–795
Rathus S A, ‘Temelji psihologije’ [‘Essentials of Psychology’] (5th edition, Slap, Zagreb, 2001)
Rest R J, ‘Development in Judging Moral Issues’ (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, 1992)
Rhode D L, ‘Ethics by the Pervasive Method’ (1992) 42(1) Journal of Legal Education, 31–56
Rhode D L, ‘Legal Ethics in Legal Education’ (2009) 16(1) Clinical Law Review, 43–56
Rohan M J, ‘A rose by any name? The values construct’ (2000) 4(3) Personality and social psychology review, 255–277
Rokeach M, ‘The nature of human values’ (Free press, New York, 1973)
Sheffield M A and others, ‘Adolescent Moral Development’ in Brown B B and Prinstein M J (eds), Encyclopedia of Adolescence, Normative processes in development (1, Academic Press, 2011) 48–55
Schlaefli A and Rest J R and Thoma S J, ‘Does moral education improve moral judgment? A meta-analysis of intervention studies using the Defining Issues Test’ (1985) 55(3) Review of educational research, 319–352
Schwartz S H, ‘Universals in the content and structure of values: Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries’ (1992) 25 Advances in experimental social psychology, 1-65
Schwartz S H, ‘Are there universal aspects in the structure and contents of human values?’ (1994) 50(4) Journal of social issues, 19–45
Stipić I, ‘Uloga Kohlbergove teorije moralnog razvoja u kontekstu odgoja za vrijednosti’ [‘The role of Kohlberg's theory of moral development in the context of values education’] (Master's thesis, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Split, 2021)
Strahovnik V, ‘Ethics and values education’ in Peters M A (ed), Encyclopedia of Educational Philosophy and Theory (Singapore, Springer, 2016) 769–774
Strahovnik V, ‘Ethical education and moral theory’ (2018) 25(2) Metodički ogledi: časopis za filozofiju odgoja, 11–29
Susskind R, ‘Tomorrow's Lawyers: An Introduction to Your Future’ (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2023)
Sutrop M, ‘Can values be taught? The myth of value-free education’ (2015) 19(2) Trames, 189–202
Thomas PhJ, ‘Dare to Bare: Get a Vision and Reveal It’ (1997) 30(2) De Jure, 364–374
Townes J C, ‘Organization and Operation of a Law School’ (1910) 33 Annual Report of the American Bar Association, 966–989
Vallance E, ‘Hiding the hidden curriculum: An interpretation of the language of justification in nineteenth-century educational reform’, in Giroux H A and Purpel D E (eds), The hidden curriculum and moral education: Deception or discovery? (McCutchan Publishing, Berkeley, 1983) 9–27
Van Dongen E and Raaijmakers S, ‘The Development of Moral Reasoning in the Law Curriculum - An Exploration of Various Teaching Activities’ (2022) Law and Method, 1–16
Vaughan J L and Estes T H, ‘Reading and reasoning beyond the primary grades’ (Allyn & Bacon, Boston, 1986)
Vican D, ‘Odgoj i obrazovanje u Hrvatskoj u kontekstu europskih vrijednosti’ [‘Education in Croatia in the context of European values’] (2006) 3(1) Pedagogijska istraživanja, 9–19
Vizek-Vidović V and Vlahović-Štetić V, ‘Aktivno učenje i kritičko mišljenje u visokoškolskoj nastavi’ [‘Active learning and critical thinking in higher education teaching’], Priručnik za nastavnike – Aktivno učenje i ERR okvir za poučavanje (1st ed, Forum za slobodu odgoja, Zagreb, 2020)
Young P M, ‘Teaching Professional Ethics to Lawyers and Mediators Using Active Learning Techniques’ (2010) 40(1) Southwestern Law Review, 127–174
Wilson K and Korn J H, ‘Attention during Lectures: Beyond Ten Minutes’ (2007) 34(2) Teaching of Psychology, 85–89
Zimmermann R, ‘Roman and Comparative Law: The European Perspective (some remarks apropos a recent controversy)’, (1995) 16(1) The Journal of Legal History, 21–33
INTERNET SOURCES
EU Justice Scoreboard, available at: <https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/policies/justice-and-fundamental-rights/upholding-rule-law/eu-justice-scoreboard_en> accessed 13th September 2023
Defining Issues Test, The Center for the Study of Ethical Development, The University of Alabama, available at: <https://ethicaldevelopment.ua.edu/about-the-dit.html> accessed 10th September 2023
Škrinjarić B, ‘Povjerenje građana u institucije i percepcija korupcije’ [‘Citizens' trust in institutions and perception of corruption’] (EIZ commentary 26th January 2023, Ekonomski institut Zagreb) <https://eizg.hr/povjerenje-gradjana-u-institucije-i-percepcija-korupcije/6276> accessed 15th September 2023
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Nikol Žiha
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors retain the copyright on the papers published in the Journal, but grant the right of first publication to the Journal. Papers accepted for publication or already published in Pravni vjesnik of the Faculty of Law in Osijek may be published by the author(s) in other publications only with proper notice of its previous publication in Pravni vjesnik.
