CHILD REPRESENTATION IN CASES BEFORE THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/32050Keywords:
child’s representation, child’s right to be heard, the best interest of the child, guardian ad litem, conflict of interestsAbstract
Representation of the child is an integral part of the institution of parental responsibility. Holders of parental responsibility, usually the parents, represent their child equally, jointly and consensually both in everyday life and in administrative and judicial proceedings. However, in certain life situations a conflict between parents may appear (such as separation, divorce, child abduction, partial deprivation of legal capacity etc.), so the question arises as to which one of them should represent the child? Would representation of the child by only one parent disrupt the principle of parental equality as well as the equality of sexes?
In certain life situations a conflict of interests between the parents and the child may appear (because criminal, misdemeanour or family law proceedings for the protection of the rights and welfare of the child have been initiated against one or both parents etc.), and the challenge for the legal system is how to ensure objective and impartial representation of the child and his/her best interests? These are both social and legal problems that will be elaborated through relevant academic sources and recent case law of the European Court of Human Rights.
References
Aras Kramar S, 'Komentar Obiteljskog zakona – II. Knjiga' (Zagreb Organizator 2022)
Aras Kramar S and Ljubić B, 'O djelovanju Centra za posebno skrbništvo: rezultati, dvojbe i perspektiva – II. dio' (2017) 17(7–8) Hrvatska pravna revija 16–25.
Aras Kramar S and Ljubić B, 'O djelovanju Centra za posebno skrbništvo: rezultati, dvojbe i perspektiva – I. dio' (2017) 17(6) Hrvatska pravna revija 22–33.
Bruning M and Mol C, 'Child Participation in International and Regional Human Rights Instruments' in Schrama W, Freeman M, Taylor N and Bruning M (eds), International Handbook on Child Participation in Family Law (Intersentia, Cambridge – Antwerp – Chicago 2021)
Čulo Margaletić A, 'Prava djeteta u obiteljskoj medijaciji' (2017) 8(special issue) Godišnjak Akademije pravnih znanosti Hrvatske 156–165.
Čulo A, 'Pravo djeteta pacijenta na informirani pristanak' in Rešetar B (ed), Dijete i pravo (Pravni fakultet u Osijeku, Sveučilište Josipa Jurja Strossmayera 2009) 139–157.
Fenton-Glynn C, Children and the European Court of Human Rights (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2021)
Freeman M, A Magna Carta for Children?: Rethinking Children's Rights (Cambridge, United Kingdom; New York: Cambridge University Press 2020)
Hrabar D, 'Europska konvencija o ostvarivanju dječjih prava – poseban zastupnik djeteta' in Filipović G and Osmak-Franjić D (eds), Dijete u pravosudnom postupku – Primjena Europske konvencije o ostvarivanju dječjih prava (Pravobranitelj za djecu Zagreb 2012) 103–116.
Hrabar D, 'Guidelines of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on child friendly justice (2010) – family law aspect' in Kutsar D and Warming H (eds), Children and non-discrimination (Tartu, Children's Rights Erasmus Academic Network 2014) 77–90.
Hrabar D, Korać Graovac A, Majstorović, I, Čulo Margaletić A, Stažnik Š and Šimović I, Presude o skrbništvu i lišenju poslovne sposobnosti Europskoga suda za ljudska prava protiv Republike Hrvatske (Pravni fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu 2021)
Hrabar D, 'Nova procesna prava djeteta – europski pogled' (2013) 4(1) Godišnjak Akademije pravnih znanosti Hrvatske 65–76.
Khazova O. A. and Dawit Mezmur B, 'UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, Reflections on Family Law Issues in the Jurisprudence of the CRC Committee: The Convention on the Rights of the Child @ 30' in Brinig M (ed), International Survey of Family Law (Cambridge – Antwerp – Chicago, Intersentia 2019) 305–328.
Khazova O A, 'Interpreting and applying the best interests of the child: the main challenges' in M Sormunen (ed), The best interests of the child – A dialogue between theory and practice (Strasbourg, Council of Europe Publishing, 2016)
Knol Radoja K, 'Pravo na saslušanje i izražavanje mišljenja u posebnim ovršnim postupcima radi predaje djeteta i ostvarivanja osobnih odnosa s djetetom' (2021) 42(1) Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci 167–185.
Korać Graovac A, 'Pravo djeteta da bude saslušano - Opći komentar br. 12 Odbora za prava djeteta (2009)' in Filipović G and Osmak-Franjić D (eds), Dijete u pravosudnom postupku – Primjena Europske konvencije o ostvarivanju dječjih prava (Pravobranitelj za djecu, Zagreb 2012) 117–137.
Lansdown G, Every child’s right to be heard a resource guide on the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child General Comment no.12 (Unicef, The Save the Children Fund 2011)
Lucić N, 'Child’s special guardian – International and European expectations and Croatian reality' (2021) 17 Balkan Social Science Review 97–117.
Lucić N, 'Zastupanje u vezi s bitnim osobnim pravima djeteta' (2021) 5(3) Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Splitu 815–840.
Majstorović I, 'O odjecima strasbourškog acquisa u hrvatskom Obiteljskom zakonu iz 2015. godine' in Bubić S (ed), The reflections of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights in national family legislations (Mostar Law Faculty – University Džemal Bijedić 2017) 101–117.
Majstorović I, 'The Realisation of the right of the child to express his/her views – How “visible” are children in Croatian family judicial proceedings?' (2017) 24(1) Ljetopis socijalnog rada 55–71.
Mol C, 'Children's representation in family law proceedings' (2019) 27(1) International Journal of Children's Rights 66–98.
Parkinson P and Cashmore J, The Voice of a Child in Family Law Disputes (Oxford University Press, New York 2008)
Radina A, 'Praksa suda i posebnog skrbnika u postupcima radi odlučivanja o mjerama zaštite osobnih prava i dobrobiti djeteta' in Rešetar B and Aras S (eds), Represivne mjere za zaštitu osobnih prava i dobrobiti djeteta – Interdisciplinarni, komparativni i međunarodni osvrti (Osijek, Sveučilište J. J. Strossmayera u Osijeku Pravni fakultet 2014) 23–39.
Rešetar B and Rupić D, 'Posebni skrbnik za dijete u hrvatskom i njemačkom obiteljskopravnom sustavu' (2016) 37(3) Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci 1175–1198.
Rittossa D, ‘Strengthening the Rights of Sexually Abused Children in front of the European Court of Human Rights – a Tale of Justice, Fairness and Constant Normative Evolution’ (2020) 4 EU 2020 – Lessons from the Past and Solutions for the Future, EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC) 529–556.
Šimović I, 'Procesna sposobnosti i pravne radnje djeteta' in Hrabar D (ed), Obiteljsko pravo (Zagreb Narodne novine 2021) 192–195.
Šimović I, 'The right of the child to be heard in the Croatian family law system' (2023) 19(1) European Integration Studies
Turković K, Roksandić Vidlička S and Brozović J, 'Informirani pristanak djece u hrvatskom zakonodavstvu' in Turković K, Roksandić Vidlička S and Maršavelski A (eds), Hrestomatija hrvatskoga medicinskog prava (Pravni fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu 2016) 572–584.
Zermatten J, 'The Best Interests of the Child Principle: Literal Analysis and Function' (2010) 18 International Journal of Children’s Rights 483–499.
REGULATIONS AND DOCUMENTS
Constitution of the Republic of Croatia (Official Gazette, Nos. 56/1990, 135/1997, 8/1998, 113/2000, 124/2000, 28/2001, 41/2001, 55/2001, 76/10, 85/2010, 5/2014) (CRO)
Convention on the rights of the Child (CRC)
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)
European Convention on the Exercise of Children's Rights (ECECR, Council of Europe, 1996)
Family Act (Official Gazette, Nos. 103/2015, 98/2019, 47/2020, 49/2023, 156/2023) (CRO)
General Comment No. 12 (2009) on the right of the child to be heard, UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC), CRC/C/GC/12, 20 July 2009
General Comment No. 14 (2013) on the right of the child to have his or her best interests taken as a primary consideration (art. 3, para. 1), UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC), CRC/C/GC/14, 29 May 2013
Guidelines of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on child-friendly justice, Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe,17 November 2010
Special Guardianship Centre Act (Official Gazette No. 47/20) (CRO)
JUDGMENTS AND OTHER DECISIONS
A. and B. v. Croatia (App. No. 7144/15, 20 June 2019)
A. M. and Others v. Russia (App. No. 47220/19, 6 July 2021)
C. v. Croatia (App. No. 80117/17, 8 October 2020)
E. M. and Others v. Norway (Appl. No. 53471/17, 20 January 2022)
H. P. and others v. Croatia (App. No. 58282/19, 19 May 2022)
Hromadka and Hromadkova v. Russia (Appl. No. 22909/10, 11 December 2014)
K. B. and Others v. Croatia (App. No. 36216/13, 14 March 2017)
L. R. v. Northern Macedonia (App. No. 38067/15, 23 January 2020)
N. TS. and Others v. Georgia (App. No. 71776/12, 2 February 2016)
Petrov and X. v. Russia (App. No. 23608/16, 23 October 2018)
R. B. and M. v. Italy (App. No. 41382/19, 22 April 2021)
T. A. and Others v. the Republic of Moldova (App. No. 25450/20, 30 November 2021)
INTERNET SOURCES
Annual Report on the work of the Ombudsman for children (2023), available at: <https://dijete.hr/en/izvjesca/izvjesca-o-radu-pravobranitelja-za-djecu/> accessed 5th May 2024.
Mol C, 'Strengthening Child Participation rights in the Case Law of the ECtHR: A Plea to Consider Child participation systematically from a Children’s rights perspective', <https://www.humanrightsincontext.be/post/strengthening-child-participation-rights-in-the-case-law-of-the-ecthr> accessed 5th May 2024.
Erdem Türkelli G, 'Who can represent a child (with disabilities) before the ECtHR? Locus Standi requirements and the issue of curator ad litem in L.R. v. North Macedonia' Strasbourg Observers, 2020 URL: <https://strasbourgobservers.com/2020/02/27/who-can-represent-a-child-with-disabilities-before-the-ecthr-locus-standi-requirements-and-the-issue-of-curator-ad-litem-in-l-r-v-north-macedonia> accessed 5th May 2024.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Anica Čulo Margaletić, Ivan Šimović
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors retain the copyright on the papers published in the Journal, but grant the right of first publication to the Journal. Papers accepted for publication or already published in Pravni vjesnik of the Faculty of Law in Osijek may be published by the author(s) in other publications only with proper notice of its previous publication in Pravni vjesnik.
