INTRODUCTION
UVOD
Plant communities are formed by the plants distributing in similar environmental conditions and form the general vegetation structure in a region. Defining plant communities is crucial in determining plant biodiversity, understanding ecological differentiation, and assessing habitat diversity (Blasi and Burrascano 2013). Such knowledge is very important for the management of natural resources and especially for nature conservation studies.
In order to carry out largescale studies on vegetation analysis, it is necessary to determine the plant communities at the local scale. In this context, it is seen that studies on plant communities are intensive around the world and have been conducted to a large extent, especially in Europe (Chytrý et al. 2016). As a matter of fact, comprehensive vegetation databases for European vegetation, based on the studies carried out on a local scale, have been constituted, and comprehensive classifications have been carried out. Based on these databases, European habitat classification has almost been completed, and the distribution of plant communities at the alliance level has been mapped (Chytrý et al. 2020; Preislerová et al. 2022).
The number of plant sociology studies in Türkiye intensified in the 1970s, especially with the contributions of foreign researchers. In the following years, these numbers increased with the participation of Turkish researchers who were interested in the subject, and a substantial contribution was made to the vegetation sciences in Türkiye (Quézel et al. 1992; Ketenoğlu et al. 2010; Bergmeier et al. 2018). Based on these studies, some largescale datasets were prepared and analyzed, such as the Forest Vegetation Database of Turkey (Kavgacı et al. 2021), oak forest vegetation in Turkey (Uğurlu et al. 2012), and western Euxine forest vegetation of Turkey (Çoban and Willner 2019). With the vegetation studies based on these datasets, significant contributions to the understanding of the vegetation and habitat diversity of the country were made. However, enriching these datasets with data from previously unstudied regions is important to better understand the diversity at the country level and to contribute to the European vegetation classification system (Mucina et al. 2016).
In addition to the studies carried out in different parts of Türkiye, SW Türkiye was also subjected to several phytosociological studies, such as by Vural et al. (1995), Özel (1996), and Kavgacı et al. (2017, 2021). However, the Bencik Mountain located in the Muğla province (SW Türkiye), one of the high plant biodiversity regions in Türkiye, was not studied, and to understand the diversity and richness at a regional scale, the determination of the vegetation diversity of this mountain is crucial. Therefore, in this study, it was aimed to determine the plant communities of the Bencik Mountain vegetation, reveal their relationship with topographical variables, and evaluate them in terms of plant biodiversity parameters. The south and southwest of Türkiye are plant biodiversity hotspots, and the study area is located in this region. It is thought that the study carried out at this location would make a significant contribution to the vegetation science.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
MATERIJAL I METODE
Study area – Istraživano područje
The study area, which is located in southwestern Türkiye, is within the borders of the Yatağan district of the Muğla province (Figure 1). The region is situated within the Mediterranean phytogeographical boundaries. The elevation of the Bencik Mountain area varies between 400 m and 1396 m.
The bedrock of the study area consists of marble, phyllite, and schists from the upper Paleozoic and Mesozoic periods (Kayan 1979). There are colluvial, limeless brown, brown, and redbrown Mediterranean soils that exist in the study area (Anonymous 1998).
A less rainy and warm Mediterranean climate is seen in the region. The average temperature is 16.2°C, the average precipitation is 631.74 mm, the coldest and warmest months are February and July, respectively (Meteorology General Directorate 2018).
Field sampling and data assessment – Terensko uzorkovanje i analiza podataka
The field sampling was carried out on the Bencik Mountain (Yatağan/MuğlaTürkiye) between 2016 and 2019. For the definition of the plant associations, sampling plots were taken from each plant formation in an adequate number and suitable size. In addition to the forest and shrubland vegetation in the study area, the regressive successional stage, especially in contact with Quercus coccifera machia, and sclerophyllous forests were also sampled to understand the effects of degradation. The protocol of each plot includes general topographic and other data of individual plots, such as elevation, inclination, aspect, vegetation cover (total and individual layers), and a list of all vascular plants, in which a cover value was assigned to each species according to the cover – abundance scale of BraunBlanquet (1932).

Figure 1. Geographic map of the research area (Abbreviations: Q: Quarter, H: Hill, L: Location).
Slika 1. Karta istraživanog područja (Kratice: Q: predio, H: vrh, L: lokalitet)
For the classification analyses, the Sorensen (BrayCurtis) coefficient as a resemblance measure and Ward’s method as a group linkage method were applied in the PCORD program (Versions 4 and 5). The diagnostic species of the accepted clusters were identified by a fidelity measure in the JUICE (version 7.1) program (Tichý 2002). The threshold of the phi value was subjectively selected at 0.50 for a species to be considered diagnostic (Chytrý et al. 2002). Species whose occurrence concentration in the plots of a particular cluster was not significant at p<0.05 (Fisher´s exact test) were excluded from the set of diagnostic species (Tichý and Chytrý 2006). Species with 50% frequency in each plant community were accepted as constant species, and species with a cover of more than 25% in at least 10% of the vegetation plots in each community were considered as dominant species.
The results of the classification were visualized by ordination techniques in nonmetric multidimensional scaling (NMDS). Topographical variables (elevation, aspect, and inclination) were passively shown on the ordination plane. Moreover, the topographical variables were visualized by a boxwishers diagram prepared in JUICE. The nomenclature of plant species follows the Flora of Turkey (Davis 1965–1985; Davis et al. 1988) and the Plant List of Turkey (Güner (ed.) 2012). The IUCN categories of the endemic taxa collected from the study area were determined from the Red Book of Turkish Plants (Ekim et al., 2000; IUCN, 2003). New syntaxa were described in accordance with the International Code of Phytosociological Nomenclature (ICPN; Theurillat et al. 2021).
RESULTS
REZULTATI
Classification – Klasifikacija
The classification analyses showed that the Bencik Mountain vegetation is formed by five different plant communities representing different vegetation types: forests, macchia and regressive successional stage (Figure 2).
The vegetation table of the communities is submitted in Table 1 (see in Apendix).

Figure 2. Dendrogram of the Bencik Mountain vegetation by the hier- archical cluster analysis (1. Hymenocarpos circinnatus-Pinus brutia for- est, 2. Daphne gnidioides-Quercus coccifera macchia, 3. Nerium ole- ander-Platanus orientalis forest, 4. Vicia lathyroides-Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest, 5. Aegilops triuncialis-Clypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage).
Slika 2. Dendrogram vegetacije na planini Bencik dobiven hijerarhijskom klasterskom analizom (1. šuma Hymenocarpos circinnatus-Pinus brutia, 2. makija Daphne gnidioides-Quercus coccifera, 3. šuma Nerium oleander- Platanus orientalis, 4. šuma Vicia lathyroides-Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana, 5. garig Aegilops triuncialis-Clypeola jonthlaspi).
Hymenocarpos circinnatus-Pinus brutia forest
This forest represents the Turkish red pine dominated forests in the area. It is mainly found between 647 m and 1094 m. Above this belt, it represents a nonhomogeneous structure and mixes with Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana at ecotones up to an elevation about 1200 m. It appears to have almost all kinds of aspects with the inclination between 10° and 45°. Soil types are limeless brown and brown forest soil consisting of marble and schist rocks. The general coverage of the community is between 75% and 95%. The community consists of three vertical layers. The tree layer cover is 70–90% with 20–30 m height; the shrub layer is 15–60% with 0.14 m height; and the herb cover is 30–95% with 0.6–1.1 m height.
Diagnostic species: Asplenium ceterach, Briza maxima, Cen- taurea cariensis subsp. maculiceps, Cistus creticus, Crepis ve- sicaria, Crucianella latifolia, Dactylis glomerata subsp. his- panica, Galium heldreichii, Hymenocarpos circinnatus, Lathyrus aphaca var. affinis, Pilosella piloselloides subsp. pi- loselloides, Pinus brutia var. brutia, Quercus ithaburensis subsp. macrolepis, Sanguisorba minor subsp. minor, Scandix australis subsp. grandiflora, Scorzonera elata, Spiranthes spi- ralis, Trifolium uniflorum
Constant species: Asplenium ceterach, Briza maxima, Bro- mus sterilis, Carex flacca subsp. erythrostachys, Cistus creti- cus, Crepis vesicaria, Crucianella latifolia, Cynosurus echina- tus, Dactylis glomerata subsp. hispanica, Doronicum orientale, Euphorbia rigida, Galium heldreichii, Hymenocar- pos circinnatus, Lathyrus aphaca var. affinis, Milium pedice- llare, Oryzopsis coerulescens, Pilosella piloselloides subsp. pi- loselloides, Pinus brutia, Poa bulbosa, Quercus coccifera, Quercus ithaburensis subsp. macrolepis, Sanguisorba minor subsp. minor, Scandix australis subsp. grandiflora, Scorzo- nera elata, Torilis arvensis subsp. neglecta, Trifolium campe- stre, Trifolium grandiflorum, Trifolium stellatum var. stella- tum, Trifolium uniflorum.
Dominant species: Pinus brutia
Daphne gnidioides-Quercus coccifera macchia
Daphne gnidioidesQuercus coccifera macchia is found between the elevations of 663 and 748 m. It generally appears in the northern, northeastern, eastern, and southern aspects. The inclination changes between 5° and 30°. It is located on brown forest soil, which consists of phyllite rocks. The general cover of the vegetation type is between 70% and 90%. The vegetation type consists of two vegetation layers. The shrub layer cover is 7090% with the height of 0.56 m, and the herb cover is 1060% with the height of 0.71.5 m.
Diagnostic species: Aegilops umbellulata, Caucalis platycar- pos, Daphne gnidioides, Euphorbia rigida, Lagoecia cumino- ides, Legousia speculum-veneris, Minuartia anatolica var. anatolica, Securigera cretica, Sherardia arvensis, Styrax offi cinalis, Trifolium lucanicum
Constant species: Aegilops umbellulata, Alyssum smyrna- eum, Asparagus acutifolius, Avena barbata subsp. barbata, Bromus sterilis, Carex flacca subsp. erythrostachys, Caucalis platycarpos, Cistus creticus, Crucianella latifolia, Daphne gnidioides, Euphorbia rigida, Geranium lucidum, Lagoecia cuminoides, Legousia speculumveneris, Leontodon tubero- sus, Medicago minima var. minima, Minuartia anatolica var. anatolica, Oryzopsis coerulescens, Poa bulbosa, Quercus coccifera, Sanguisorba verrucosa, Scandix stellata, Securigera cretica, Sherardia arvensis, Silene odontopetala, Stachys cre- tica subsp. smyrnaea, Styrax officinalis, Torilis arvensis subsp. neglecta, Trifolium lucanicum, Trifolium stellatum var. stellatum.
Dominant species: Quercus coccifera.
Nerium oleander-Platanus orientalis forest
Riparian forests on the Bencik Mountain are formed by this vegetation type ranging between 501 and 565 m. The vegetation type is found on the limeless brown soil formed by the phyllite rock. It generally prefers southern aspects. The inclination is not high. The general cover of the vegetation type is between 60% and 70%. The vegetation type consists of three vertical layers. The tree layer cover is 4570% and the height is 1025 m; the shrub layer cover is 4570% and the height is 36 m; the herb layer cover is 560%, and the height is 1 m.
Diagnostic species: Campanula lyrata subsp. lyrata, Cratae- gus monogyna subsp. monogyna, Dracunculus vulgaris, Eu- phorbia peplus var. peplus, Geranium purpureum, Hedera helix, Juncus acutus, Mentha longifolia, Micromeria graeca subsp. graeca, Muscari comosum, Myrtus communis subsp. communis, Nerium oleander, Plantago lanceolata, Platanus orientalis, Prunella vulgaris, Viola odorata
Constant species: Asparagus acutifolius, Briza maxima, Campanula lyrata subsp. lyrata, Crataegus monogyna subsp. monogyna, Crepis sancta, Dactylis glomerata subsp. hispanica, Dracunculus vulgaris, Euphorbia peplus var. peplus, Ge- ranium purpureum, Hedera helix, Juncus acutus, Mentha longifolia, Micromeria graeca subsp. graeca, Muscari como- sum, Myrtus communis subsp. communis, Nerium oleander, Plantago lanceolata, Platanus orientalis, Prunella vulgaris, Sanguisorba minor subsp. muricata, Trifolium campestre, Vi- ola odorata.
Dominant species: Nerium oleander, Platanus orientalis.
Vicia lathyroides-Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest
This forest represents the Anatolian black pinedominated forests in the region. It appears above 1231 m and forms the highest elevation belt of the mountain. It occurs on the brown forest soil, which is formed by the marble rock. The inclination changes between 30° and 45°.The general cover of the vegetation type is between 70% and 80%. The vegetation type consists of three vertical layers. The tree layer cover is 6080% with the height of 1525 m, the shrub layer cover is 510% with the height of 0.13 m, and the herb layer cover is 1080% with the height of 0.30.5 m.
Diagnostic species: Galium penduliflorum, Juniperus foeti- dissima, Lamium garganicum subsp. striatum var. striatum, Origanum hypericifolium, Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana, Vi- cia lathyroides
Constant species: Anthemis cretica subsp. albida, Aubrieta deltoidea, Doronicum orientale, Galium pendulifolium, Ju- niperus foetidissima, Lamium garganicum subsp. striatum var. striatum, Milium pedicellare, Origanum hypericifolium, Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana, Poa bulbosa, Quercus cocci- fera, Veronica cymbalaria, Vicia lathyroides.
Dominant species: Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana.
Aegilops triuncialis-Clypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage
Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage has developed around 12991396 m. The vegetation type is located on brown forest soil, which consists of marble rocks found in the Fire Tower area, Buruncuk Hill, and their surroundings in the area. The inclination changes between5° and 45°. It can be found at almost all kind of aspects. The general coverage of this vegetation type is 6090%: (a) tree layer, 310%, a height of 00.1 m; (b) shrub layer, 590%, a height of 0.12 m; (c) herb layer, 5090 %, a height of 0.20.5 m. Q. coccifera, one of the most characteristic species of macchia vegetation in the region often occurs as dominant in this community. Although Q. cocci- fera represents reduced distribution and does not appear through all distribution of the vegetation type, its local dominancy may be an indication of the regression and successional process of the Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage.
Diagnostic species: Aegilops triuncialis, Anchusa hybrida, Buglossoides arvensis, Centaurea cadmea, Centaurea urvillei, Clypeola jonthlaspi, Cyanus segetum, Erodium cicutarium, Lamium amplexicaule, Moenchia mantica, Neslia paniculata subsp. thracica, Ornithogalum armeniacum, Papaver arge- mone, Saxifraga tridactylites, Scandix iberica, Sedum album, Sedum amplexicaule, Valantia hispida, Valerianella balansae
Constant species: Aegilops triuncialis, Ajuga chamaepitys, Alyssum fulvescens var. fulvescens, Alyssum smyrnaeum, Anchusa hybrida, Anthemis cretica subsp. albida, Aubrieta deltoidea, Bromus hordeaceus subsp. hordeaceus, Buglosso- ides arvensis, Centaurea cadmea, Centaurea urvillei, Clype- ola jonthlaspi, Crepis sancta, Cyanus segetum, Erodium ci- cutarium, Lamium amplexicaule, Moenchia mantica, Myosotis ramosissima, Neslia paniculata subsp. thracica, Or- nithogalum armeniacum, Papaver argemone, Poa bulbosa, Ranunculus marginatus, Saxifraga tridactylites, Scandix ibe- rica, Sedum album, Sedum amplexicaule, Trifolium stellatum var. stellatum, Valantia hispida, Valerianella balansae, Ver- bascum pinardii.
Dominant species: Quercus coccifera.
Chorology and ordination of the vegetation units –
Horologija i ordinacija vegetacijskih jedinica
It was found that the vegetation types in the study area generally contain Mediterranean elements due to their location in the Mediterranean phytogeographic region. As the altitude increases in the communities, the effect of IranoTuranian elements is found, and in humid and shaded areas, there are EuroSiberian elements.
Hymenocarpos circinnatusPinus brutia forest has a total of fiftytwo taxa, containing 42.3% Mediterranean, 57.7% pluriregional elements, and 2 LC (Least Concern) category endemics. Sideritis albiflora and Stachys cretica subsp. smyr- naea are the endemics of the community. Daphne gnidioi- desQuercus coccifera macchia has a total of fortysix taxa, containing 43.48% Mediterranean, 4.35% EuroSiberian,
6.52% IranoTuranian, 45.65% pluriregional elements, and 3 LC) category endemics. Minuartia anatolica var. anato- lica, Stachys cretica subsp. smyrnaea, and Verbascum bellum are the endemics in the community. Nerium oleanderPla- tanus orientalis forest has a total of fourteen taxa, containing 15% Mediterranean, 5% EuroSiberian, and 80% pluriregional elements. Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest contains 28.57% Mediterranean and 71.43% pluriregional elements, with 2 endemics in the LC category. The endemic species in the community are Ga- lium penduliflorum and Origanum hypericifolium. Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage has a total of fiftytwo taxa, containing 26.92% Mediterranean, 1.92% European Siberian, 3.85% Iranian Turanian, and 67.31% pluriregional elements, and 2 LC (Least Concern), 1 NT (Near Threatened), 1 VU (Vulnerable), and 1 CR (Critically Endangered) endemic taxa. Astragalus con- densatus and Astragalus hirsutus are in the LC category, Erysimum carium is in the CR category, Phlomis angusti- ssima is in the VU category, and Verbascum pinardii is in the NT category of endemics (Table 2).
The NMDS ordination of the relevés with the passive projection of topographical factors is seen in Figure 3. The floristic differentiation of the vegetation types and the effects of topographical factors on their differentiation are clear. The left side of the ordination is formed by the Hymenocar- pos circinnatusPinus brutia forest, while the Aegilops triun- cialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage occurs on the right side. Daphne gnidioidesQuercus cocci- fera macchia is at the upper part of the ordination, and the lower side is formed by the vegetation types of Nerium ole- anderPlatanus orientalis and Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forests. There is a clear gradient of elevation and aspect through axes 1 and 2, respectively.
Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forests and Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage are found in highaltitude belts of the mountain (Figures 3, 4). The Hymenocarpos circinnatusPinus brutia forest is found from the lower to the higher elevations. On the other hand, the communities of Daphne gnidioidesQu- ercus coccifera macchia and Nerium oleanderPlatanus ori- entalis forest are found at lower elevations.
Table 2. Distribution of taxa in phytogeographic regions in the study area. Tablica 2. Raširenost taksona u fitogeografskim regijama na području istraživanja.

Figure 3. NMDS ordination of the vegetation types: 1. Hymenocarpos circinnatus-Pinus brutia forest, 2. Daphne gnidioides-Quercus coccifera macchia, 3. Nerium oleander-Platanus orientalis forest, 4. Vicia lathyroides-Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest, 5. Aegilops triuncialis-Clype-ola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage)
Slika 3. NMDS ordinacija vegetacijskih tipova: 1. šuma Hymenocarpos circinnatus-Pinus brutia, 2. makija Daphne gnidioides-Quercus coccifera, 3. šuma
Nerium oleander-Platanus orientalis, 4. šuma Vicia lathyroides-Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana, 5. garig Aegilops triuncialis-Clype-ola jonthlaspi
While the forests of Nerium oleanderPlatanus orientalis prefer southern aspects, Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pa- llasiana mostly occur in northern aspects. Other vegetation types do not show specific preferences in terms of aspect.
The Nerium oleanderPlatanus orientalis forest is found on low inclinations. It has been determined that other vegetation types are located on inclinations between 10° and 45°.
Figure 4. Box-whisker diagrams of topographical variables for each plant community on the Bencik Mountain.
Slika 4. Box-whisker dijagrami topografskih varijabli za pojedine biljne za- jednice na planini Bencik.
There is a clear difference between plant communities in terms of species richness and diversity (Figures 3, 5). The Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest has the least species richness among the vegetation types.The Shannon diversity index also shows that the Vicia lathyro- idesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forests have low species diversity compared to the other vegetation types (Figure 5).

Figure 5. Box-whisker diagrams species richness and diversity for each vegetation type on the Bencik Mountain.
Slika 5. Box-whisker dijagrami topografskih varijabli za bogatstvo i razno- likost vrsta za svaki vegetacijski na planini Bencik.
See Figures 2 and 3 for the explanation of group numbers. – : Median, : 25%-75%, I : Non-outlier range, : outliers, : extremes Oznake zajednica objašnjene su na Slikama 2. i 3. – : Medijan, : 25 %-75 %, I : Raspon koji nije izuzetak, : ekstremi, : krajnosti
DISCUSSION
RASPRAVA
The vegetation of the Bencik Mountain is distributed in the mesoMediterranean and the supraMediterranean belts, consisting of five different plant communities. Although topographic conditions seem to have an effect on the floristic differentiation of the communities, secondary communities have also emerged as a result of humaninduced deterioration. In addition to zonal pine forests of P. brutia and
P. nigra, the riparian ecosystems in the area are characterized by the Platanus orientalis dominated forests.
The effects of elevation and aspect on floristic differentiation can be the result of climatic variation in the study area, which has also been shown in various studies carried out in Mediterranean Türkiye before (Fontaine et al. 2007). The upper belts of the study area are formed by the Vicia lathyroidesPi- nus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest and Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage, while the Daphne gnidioidesQuercus coccifera macchia and Nerium oleanderPlatanus orientalis forests occur in the lower belts. Differently, Hymenocarpos circinnatusPinus brutia forest is found in mesoand supraMediterranean vegetation belts.
Although P. brutia (Turkish red pine) forests in Türkiye were classified under different alliances in the past, they were grouped under two alliances in recent years (Bonari et al. 2021; Kavgacı et al. 2021). While lowerelevation Turkish red pine forests are classified under the alliance Pinion brutiae, upper ones represent the alliance Styraco officina- lisPinion brutiae. Both alliances are placed under Pinetalia halepensis and Pinetea halepensis. In our case, since the distribution of Pinus brutia forests is in mesoand supraMediterranean, it is suitable to place them under Styraco offi- cinalisPinion brutiae.
Some plant communities of Turkish red pine at association level in SW Türkiye were identified. While some of them were invalidly published according to the ICPN rules (Theurillat et al. 2021), some show certain floristic differentiation from the community on the Bencik Mountain due to the geographical and climatic variation. AetheorhizaPine- tum brutiae and Phlomido bourgaeiPinetum brutiae, both of which were described in Marmaris province by Vural et al. (1995) and Akman et al. (1998), respectively, and Juni- pero phoeniceaePinetum brutiae in the Bodrum peninsula (Akman et al. 1998) are the Turkish pine forests identified in SW Türkiye. However, all these communities represent the Euand thermoMediterranean distributions of the species (Pinion brutiae) and are floristically different. There are also other studies from higher elevation in the surrounding regions in Southern Mediterranean Türkiye: Asparago acu- tifoli-Pinetum brutiae identified in the Finike province (Antalya) (Karaköse and Terzioğlu 2021), and Glycyrrhizo asymetricae-Pinetum brutiae, and Phlomido leucophractae-Pinetum brutiae in the Antalya Gulf (Kurt et al. 2015). Similarly, there are also other studies from the northern part of Mediterranean Türkiye (Ketenoğlu et al. 2010). All of these communities have a different floristic composition than the Turkish pine forests on the Bencik Mountain (Hymenocarpos circinnatusPinus brutia forest). Therefore, we decided to describe a new association of P. brutia forests on the Bencik Mountain as Hymenocarpo circinnatiPi- netum brutiae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova under the alliance Styraco officinalisPinion brutiae (Pinetalia halepensis and Pinetea halepensis).
Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana has a natural distribution in southern Europe and Türkiye. The Anatolian black pine (Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana) is one of the subspecies of black pine, growing naturally as a widespread midelevation species in the southern, western, and northern Anatolian Mountains (Akman 1995). Its distribution is placed in a gradient from the seaeffected climate area to the steppe vegetation of inner Anatolia. Anatolian black pine forests in Türkiye were grouped under two different alliances: Ci- sto laurifolii-Pinion pallasianae in western Euxine Türkiye and Adenocarpo complicati-Pinion pallasianae in Mediterranean Türkiye (Akman, 1995; Ketenoğlu et al. 2010). Phytosociological studies were carried out in Anatolian black pine forests in SW Türkiye, some of which were not published. But these studies (see Bekat 1987; Gemici 1988; Serin 1996; Kargıoğlu and Tatlı 2005; Sağlam 2007) represent the inner land distributions of Anatolian black pine in SW Türkiye and show strict floristic differentiation from the Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest on the Bencik Mountain, which is under the effect of sea climate. In addition to these studies, other community descriptions of Anatolian black pine forests were also made in other parts of Mediterranean Türkiye. However, they also have stricter floristic differentiation than the community on the Bencik Mountain due to the geographical distance and climatic variation. In this context, the Vicia lathyroidesPinus nigra subsp. pallasiana forest on the Bencik Mountain is defined as a new association: Vicio lathyroidisPinetum pallasianae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova under AdenocarpoPinion pa- llasianae, EricoPinetalia, and EricoPinetea. The association represents the mesoMediterranean Anatolian black pine forests in areas under sea climate in SW Türkiye. The poorer species richness and diversity of this vegetation type than the other vegetation types in the region can be a result of higher tree layer coverage.
Platanus orientalis (Oriental plane) establishes gallerytype forests on narrow valley bases and along rivers in almost every region of Türkiye. There are few studies on the Oriental plane in Mediterranean Türkiye (Ayaşlıgil 1987; Çinbilgel and Gökçeoğlu 2010). The Nerio oleandriPlata- netum orientalis vegetation type, which was first identified in Albania (Kárpáti 1962), also characterizes the P. orientalis riparian forests in Anatolia. This association is placed under Platanion orientalis, Populetalia albae, and Alno glu- tinosaePopuletea albae.
Macchia is an evergreen, sclerophyllous shrubland with a more or less closed canopy structure. It is a stage of vegetation succession towards the forest, a replacement stage of climax forests, or even permanent communities on xeric sites. These stages are maintained by grazing, forest clearing, and fires. Unless the succession is interrupted, macchia develops into a sclerophyllous forest, but the species composition is nearly the same (Kavgacı et al. 2017). Macchia and sclerophyllous forests are therefore often treated together in vegetation classification (Čarni et al. 2011, 2018; Kavgacı et al. 2017).
Quercus cocciferadominated macchia and sclerophyllous forests in Türkiye are classified under different alliances: Arbuto andrachnesQuercion cocciferae, Ceratonia siliquaePistacion lentisci and Quercion cocciferae (Kavgacı et al. 2021). However, the upland disturbances with poorer Mediterranean species support classification under Quercion cocciferae. The Daphne gnidioidesQuercus coccifera macchia on the Bencik Mountain was classified under the alliance Quercion cocciferae of Quercetalia cocciferae and Quercetea ilicis. Such upland Quercus coccifera macchia and sclerophyllous forests were intensively subjected to phytosociological studies. However, most of them were not published, as shown in the supplementary material by Kavgacı et al. (2021). The identified associations of Quercion cocci- ferae in SW Türkiye were identified (Sağlam 2013; Karaköse and Terzioğlu 2021) and it can be seen that they include a different floristic composition than the one on the Bencik Mountain. They also appear on calcareous bedrock differently from the Daphne gnidioidesQuercus coccifera macchia since they prefer phyllite rocks. Quercus coccifera also has distributions in other parts of the Mediterranean basin beyond Türkiye, but represents a different syntaxonomical ranking (see Tsiourlis et al. 2009). Therefore, we decided to describe the Daphne gnidioidesQuercus coccifera macchia as a new association: Daphno gnidioisQuercetum cocciferae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova under Quercion cocci- ferae, Quercetalia cocciferae, and Quercetea ilicis.
Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi is a regressive successional stage and as seen by the floristic composition, Q. coccifera appears as the only dominant species in this community. However, it represents local dominancy, and the rest of the vegetation type shows open habitat character. The low distribution of Q. coccifera and the high presence of annual and ruderal plants indicate the grazing effect and degradation of upland Q. coccifera shrubland in the study area. The Q. coccifera communities are frequently subject to anthropogenic pressures such as fires, clearing, and overgrazing (Türkmen and Düzenli 2005), which result in a regressive ruderal vegetation type (Jasprica et al. 2016).
Since there is not sufficient knowledge on regressive successional stage ecosystems in the study regions and a specific assessment is required for them, a syntaxonomic classification has not been done for this vegetation type.
According to the syntaxonomical assessment carried out above, the syntaxonomical scheme is formed as follow:
Syntaxonomical scheme – Sintaksonomska shema
Pinetea halepensis Bonari et Chytrý in Bonari et al. 2021
Pinetalia halepensis Biondi, Blasi, Galdenzi, Pesaresi et Vagge 2014
Styraco officinalisPinion brutiae Bonari et al. 2021
Hymenocarpo circinnatiPinetum brutiae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova (Holotypus: Table 1, relevé: 2)
Quercetea ilicis Br.Bl. ex A. Bolòs et O. de Bolòs in A. Bolòs y Vayreda 1950
Quercetalia cocciferae Zohary 1955
Quercion cocciferae Zohary 1955.
Daphno gnidioisQuercetum cocciferae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova (Holotypus: Table 1, relevé 9)
EricoPinetea Horvat 1959
EricoPinetalia Horvat 1959 nom. conserv. propos. AdenocarpoPinion pallasianae Quézel, Barbero et Akman 1993 Vicio lathyroidisPinetum pallasianae Aytepe et Kavgacı ass. nova (Holotypus: Table 1, relevé: 24)
Alno glutinosaePopuletea albae P. Fukarek et Fabijanić 1968 Populetalia albae Br.Bl. ex Tchou 1949 nom. conserv. propos. Platanion orientalis I. Kárpáti et V. Kárpáti 1961
Nerio oleandriPlatanetum orientalis Kárpáti and Kárpáti 1961
Aegilops triuncialisClypeola jonthlaspi regressive successional stage
The appearance of different forest and shrubland communities in a very narrow area in the study site indicate high vegetation diversity in the region. In addition to the endemism, the occurrence of endangered species in the area also show the diversity and how vulnerable it is. The regressive successional community can be accepted as the indication of the level of vegetation degradation in the area. Therefore, the sensibility of the vegetation diversity in the region must be taken into account during forest, land management and nature conservation studies.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
