Original scientific paper

Carnap’s External Questions and Semantic Externalism

Andrei Moldovan orcid.org/0000-0002-9435-519X ; Departamento de Filosofía, Lógica y Estética, Universidad de Salamanca, Edificio F.E.S. Campus Miguel de Unamuno 37007 Salamanca, & Logos, University of Barcelona, Spain

Abstract

What is it for an utterance of an expression to lack meaning? In this paper I address the issue along the lines of Carnap’s seminal article “Empiricism, Semantics and Ontology”. Carnap provides there an answer to the above question, which he then uses to argue that certain claims of metaphysics are meaningless. In the first section of the paper I present Carnap’s argument for the meaninglessness of certain metaphysical claims. In the second section I argue that, although the argument is not compelling, the main virtue of Carnap’s proposal is the strategy he develops for generating meaningless uses of language. In the third section I propose an externalist criterion of meaningless uses of expressions that relies on semantic externalist considerations. This, I argue, bears significant resemblances to Carnap’s proposal. In the last section I discuss the applicability of the new criterion to the question concerning the meaning of metaphysical claims.

Keywords

Carnap; external vs. internal questions; externalism; meaninglessness; metaphysics

Hrčak ID:

129625

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/129625

Publication date:

19.11.2014.

Visits: 2.026 *