Original scientific paper
https://doi.org/10.31820/ejap.13.2.3
Saving the Ship
John Biro
; University of Florida
Abstract
In defending the startling claim that that there are no artifacts, indeed, no inanimate material objects of the familiar sort, Peter van Inwagen has argued that truths about such putative objects can be paraphrased as truths that do not make essential reference to them and that we should endorse only the ontological commitments of the paraphrase. In this note I argue that the paraphrases van Inwagen recommends cannot meet his condition. Read one way, they lose us some truths. Read another, they entail the existence of the very objects they are supposed to rid us of. However, we need not share van Inwagen's distaste for the latter: to say that they exist is not to say that anything exists in addition to the simples composing them.
Keywords
van Invagen; paraphrase; composites; simples
Hrčak ID:
203341
URI
Publication date:
9.7.2018.
Visits: 1.286 *