Review article

Reliabilism and Contemporary Epistemology

Zvonimir Čuljak orcid.org/0000-0002-0698-3541 ; Centre for Croatian Studies, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia

Abstract

This paper reviews some elements of contemporary reliabilism, a dominant epistemological theory, as is presented in the recent collection of essays Reliabilism and Contemporary Epistemology (2012) by a major epistemologist, Alvin I. Goldman. The focus is on Goldman’s variant of process reliabilism as a theory of epistemic justification as well as some of the arguments he provided for this theory and its rivals. According to Goldman’s process reliabilism, epistemic justification is a function of the reliability of the pertinent belief producing processes. This simple formula has been systematically developed by Goldman as a general theory of individual justified belief and knowledge. Goldman also extended his analysis in terms of reliable (truth-oriented, truth-conducive) belief production beyond the boundaries of individual epistemology into a veritistic social epistemology, formulating a general theory of social conditions of justification and knowledge as well as a theory of social knowledge. Two main themes from Reliabilism and Contemporary Epistemology are emphasized here: the structure of justification and the evidential role of intuitions. Concerning the latter topic, certain deviations from Goldman’s original reliabilist position have been noticed and critically assessed.

Keywords

Epistemic justification; Goldman; intuitions; reliabilism

Hrčak ID:

93139

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/93139

Publication date:

30.11.2012.

Visits: 4.268 *