Original scientific paper
Definite Descriptions and Quantifier Scope: Some Mates Cases Reconsidered
Michael Glanzberg
Abstract
This paper reexamines some examples, discussed by Mates and others, of sentences containing both definite descriptions and quantifiers.
It has frequently been claimed that these sentences provide evidence for the view that definite descriptions themselves are quantifiers. The main goal of this paper is to argue this is not so. Though the examples are compatible with quantificational approaches to definite descriptions,
they are also compatible with views that treat definite descriptions as basically scopeless. They thus provide no reason to see definite descriptions as quantifiers. Even so, this paper shows that the examples do raise a surprising range of complex issues about how quantifier
scope works, and where it occurs. Thus, a clear picture of how these examples work will help us to understand better where definite descriptions fit into the larger picture of quantifiers and related
phenomena.
Keywords
definite description; quantifier; scope; semantics; syntax
Hrčak ID:
93215
URI
Publication date:
30.10.2007.
Visits: 1.110 *