Skip to the main content

Reaction, polemic

https://doi.org/10.24869/psyd.2026.318

Beyond serotonin: rethinking the causes and diagnosis of depression

León Trelles ; Department of History and Philosophy of Science. Institute of Philosophy. University of the Republic, Montevideo, Uruguay *

* Corresponding author.


Full text: english pdf 370 Kb

page 318-322

downloads: 0

cite


Abstract

Depression has frequently been investigated from a neurobiological perspective, particularly through hypotheses linking depressive disorders to alterations in serotonergic and other monoaminergic systems. Although this body of research provides evidence for an association between neurobiological mechanisms and depression, it does not by itself exhaust the range of factors involved in the emergence and maintenance of depressive states. In particular, socioeconomic and environmental conditions may influence psychological and cognitive processes associated with depression. This article argues that, even if serotonergic dysfunction contributes causally to depression, a neurobiological account cannot by itself provide an exhaustive explanation of the disorder. In this article, 1) some of the research linking the development of depression to dysregulation of serotonergic activity is reviewed. 2) It is then suggested that, even if the serotonergic hypothesis can be considered correct, it fails to account for how other types of factors, such as poverty, influence the development of depression. Finally, 3) it is argued that the serotonergic hypothesis also fails to distinguish between normal states of sadness and clinical cases of depression.

Keywords

Depression; Psychiatric diagnosis; Philosophy of psychiatry; Mental Health

Hrčak ID:

353631

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/353631

Publication date:

17.11.2026.

Visits: 0 *