Review of psychology, Vol. 14 No. 2, 2007.
Original scientific paper
Teaching probability: effects of task frames and training on misconceptions
Francesca Chiesi
; University of Florence, Department of Psychology
Silvia Galli
; University of Florence, Department of Psychology
Giorgio Gronchi
; University of Florence, Department of Psychology
Caterina Primi
; University of Florence, Department of Psychology
Abstract
The aim of the present work is to improve knowledge about how students think about probability in order to find educational methods intended to eliminate misconceptions. The role of task frames and training on reasoning about sequences of independent outcomes was investigated. Three types of frames have been compared: abstract, concrete, and concrete plus reference to stereotypes. Tasks were administered to two groups of students: one group had followed a brief course on probability, the other had not. Frames influenced the use of normative strategies as well as training, whereas some students, even after the training, continued to hold misconceptions. In particular, the use of normative strategies was more likely in abstract frames. This effect held both for training and non-training group. However, training group was more prone to avoid mistakes in concrete plus reference to stereotypes frames. Results suggest that these tasks can be used to illustrate normative responses and biases in teaching probability.
Keywords
statistics education research; probabilistic reasoning; assessment
Hrčak ID:
25578
URI
Publication date:
16.5.2008.
Visits: 906 *