Skoči na glavni sadržaj

Synthesis philosophica, Vol. 33 No. 1, 2018.

Prethodno priopćenje

https://doi.org/10.21464/sp33106

Western versus African Medical Knowledge Systems. A Comparative Epistemological Analysis

Alex Egodotaye Asakitikpi orcid id orcid.org/0000-0002-9395-0544 ; Monash University South Africa, Faculty of Social and Health Sciences, 144 Peter Road Ruimsig, ZA–1725 Johannesburg

Puni tekst: engleski pdf 400 Kb

str. 91-104

preuzimanja: 842

citiraj

Puni tekst: hrvatski pdf 400 Kb

str. 91-104

preuzimanja: 388

citiraj

Puni tekst: francuski pdf 400 Kb

str. 91-104

preuzimanja: 366

citiraj

Puni tekst: njemački pdf 400 Kb

str. 91-104

preuzimanja: 352

citiraj

Sažetak

The epistemic foundation of reality, especially Western-¬derived knowledge, is often portrayed as universal and, therefore, as a given, while other forms that do not subscribe to the logic of Western paradigm are challenged and summarily dismissed as inferior to Western form and unworthy of any scientific investigation. The rhetoric of Western versus non¬Western knowledge (especially those of African tradition), seems to be characterised in patronising ways that suggest a knowledge form that is inferior to mainstream knowledge system of Western rationality. This rhetoric and ideological orientation are deeply entrenched in academic discourses regarding knowledge production and utility. For the most part, they have become entrenched in Western education and have remained dominant for centuries. The underlying assumptions of the discourse, however, remain unsubstantiated primarily because they are grounded in a scientific tradition that is antagonistic towards other forms of knowledge systems. We argue in this paper that the real difference between Western and African medical knowledge systems is not so much the outcome of the knowledge derived, but in the epistemic foundations that give rise to these knowledge systems. We contend that all forms of knowledge are contingent on specific contexts, and the evaluative criteria designed to measure their universal truth do not serve any useful function except to propagate a false hegemonic narrative for the sole purpose of domination and exploitation. We conclude by advocating for the expansion of mainstream medical knowledge by researching other forms of epistemology without prejudice.

Ključne riječi

African medicine; African medical knowledge; African healing; knowledge production; Western medical knowledge

Hrčak ID:

219843

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/219843

Datum izdavanja:

6.11.2018.

Podaci na drugim jezicima: hrvatski francuski njemački

Posjeta: 3.598 *