Skoči na glavni sadržaj

Reagiranje, polemika

https://doi.org/10.24869/psyd.2026.323

Depression as an incubation: Reply from a Jungian perspective

Aleksandar Prica ; Faculty of Philosophy, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia *

* Dopisni autor.


Puni tekst: engleski pdf 392 Kb

str. 323-328

preuzimanja: 0

citiraj


Sažetak

Background: Phenomenological psychiatry criticizes SSRI treatment by arguing that antidepressants do not restore the lived body’s resonance with the world but install a novel mode of attunement. Gruica (2026) calls this state pharmacological alienation and characterizes it by three structural features: attenuation without restoration, functional preservation coupled with relational evacuation, and a distinctive form of self-estrangement. This reply asks whether that critique goes far enough. Subjects and Methods: Conceptual and hermeneutic analysis. The phenomenological account of depression as corporealization (Fuchs) and as pathological bodily resonance (Svenaeus) is reconstructed and then confronted with Jung’s energic theory of the psyche as set out in the Collected Works — the economy of the libido, enantiodromia, and the pair progression/regression — together with its clinical elaborations in Sharp, Rosen, and Moore. Results: Phenomenological psychiatry abandons the biological substrate of the deficit model while retaining its conception of depression as a necessarily pathological state. Read energically, the energy withdrawn from the world has not vanished but turned inward: depression is a state of incubation in which contents excluded by a one-sided conscious attitude gain psychic value, permitting adaptation to the inner world and, once the state passes, better adaptation to the outer world. Only remaining stuck in this state is pathological. Conclusion: Gruica’s diagnosis should be supplemented with a fourth structural feature: alienation from one’s own psyche. All three of his features concern the subject’s relation to the world; none can register a disturbance in the relation to the unconscious, since that relation does not figure among the framework’s categories. The omission is a limit of the framework itself, not an oversight.

Ključne riječi

SSRIs; phenomenological psychiatry; pharmacological alienation depression; Jung

Hrčak ID:

353632

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/353632

Datum izdavanja:

17.11.2026.

Posjeta: 0 *