Original scientific paper

https://doi.org/10.31820/ejap.15.2.4

How Do We Know That We Are Free?

Timothy O’Connor ; Indiana University

Abstract

We are naturally disposed to believe of ourselves and others that we are free: that what we do is often and to a considerable extent ‘up to us’ via the exercise of a power of choice to do or to refrain from doing one or more alternatives of which we are aware. In this article, I probe the source and epistemic justification of our ‘freedom belief’. I propose an account that (unlike most) does not lean heavily on our first-personal experience of choice and action, and instead regards freedom belief as a priori justified. I will then consider possible replies available to incompatibilists to the contention made by some compatibilists that the ‘privileged’ epistemic status of freedom belief (which my account endorses) supports a minimalist, and therefore compatibilist view of the nature of freedom itself.

Keywords

Free will; freedom experience; incompatibilism; a priori justification; conscious awareness; revisionism

Hrčak ID:

229964

URI

https://hrcak.srce.hr/229964

Publication date:

12.12.2019.

Visits: 2.755 *